• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Phone: 3465 9332

Logo
  • Home
  • Our Team
    • Courtney Barton – Legal Practice Director & Founder
    • George Finn – Director
    • Chris Colwill – Senior Associate
    • Ellie Prior – Associate
    • Hannah Radunz – Solicitor
    • Tenayah Miano – Paralegal
    • Alice Chapman – Paralegal
    • Rachel Elaurant – Legal Assistant
  • Our Services
    • Divorce Property Settlement Lawyers
    • Family Law Spousal Maintenance
    • Superannuation Splitting & Advice Lawyers
    • Child Custody Lawyers Brisbane
    • Child Support Lawyers
    • Child Relocation Family Lawyers
    • Child Abduction Family Lawyers
    • Fixed Fee Consent Orders Brisbane
    • Binding Financial Agreements
    • Fixed Fee Divorce Lawyers
    • Domestic Violence Lawyer – DVO Domestic Violence Order
    • Family Court Process
    • Family Mediation Services Brisbane
  • Fixed Fees
  • Common questions
    • Things you need to know following separation
      • Top 10 Myths in family Law Finally Exposed
      • Honesty is the best policy – Why tell your divorce lawyer everything
      • What to do and what not to do before you separate
      • Time Limits in Property Settlement
      • Family Court Process
      • Why you should formalise your property settlement
      • Fixed Fee Consent Orders Brisbane
      • Duty of Disclosure
      • Beware: failure to disclose may derail your consent order
      • Can the court order someone to leave a house? – Ouster Orders
      • Who stays in the home after separation?
      • Property Acquired after Separation – how is it treated?
      • Top 15 things people do wrong in a property dispute
      • Finally revealed: Top 10 things people do wrong in child custody matters
      • COSTS ORDERS
      • Going back to work after Divorce
      • 6 things you MUST know before hiring a family lawyer
      • Beware the criminal consequences of false allegations of sexual abuse
      • Divorce – What you need to know
      • Petrie Family Law Expert speaks about ‘The Twelve year Itch’
    • Spousal Maintenance
      • Family Law Spousal Maintenance
      • Spousal Maintenance – Do I have to support my ex after divorce?
      • Bodilly & Hand: Spousal Maintenance ordered 17 years after separation
    • Parenting / Child Custody
      • What is sole parental responsibility?
      • How does a DVO affect parenting orders?
      • I want sole custody of my child
      • Do you want sole Custody? Here’s what NOT to do.
      • Most Common Child Custody Arrangements
      • Drug use in family law explained
      • Interim Parenting Orders
      • How to deal with false allegations in family law
      • What is substantial and significant time?
      • Am I a parent?
      • Court Ordered Paternity Test – What, Why and How
      • My ex is in contravention of a Parenting Order. What can I do?
      • Gay Couple Win Appeal on sperm donor ‘parent’
      • How to spend more time with your children
      • Parental Alienation in Family Court Disputes – Part 1
      • Parental Alienation in Family Court Disputes: Part 2
      • Im not a parent. Can I apply for a parenting order? Non-Parent Parenting orders explained.
      • Can Parenting Orders be changed?
      • When are a child’s views given weight by a Court?
      • What age can a child decide where they live?
      • Application to change parenting orders because of children’s changed views dismissed
      • When can you change your child’s surname?
      • Courtney’s Cases: Interim Orders appealed as Judge avoids determining issues
    • Hague Convention & International Child Abduction
      • Child Abduction Family Lawyers
      • Rights to return of your child if taken to a Non-Hague Convention country
    • Relocation of children & Prevention
      • Child Abduction Family Lawyers
      • Child Relocation Family Lawyers
      • Unilateral relocation of children
      • Prevention is better than Cure – Interim Relocation of Children Cases
      • International Travel with Children After Separation
      • Airport Watch List Orders / Pace Alert Orders
      • Relocation – Full Court confirms decision allowing ADF Mother a ‘blank cheque’ relocation to wherever posted in her employment
    • Protecting Assets
      • 10 tips to Protect your Assets in a de facto relationship
      • Hiding assets in a divorce
      • Injunction to stop my ex selling assets
      • Protect your assets and your family after separation
      • My ex is selling assets. What can I do??
      • Superannuation Splitting & Advice Lawyers
      • What is a Superannuation Payment Flag?
      • Dunworth & Faletti: Application for injunction to stop sale of property where jurisdiction not yet established
    • De Facto relationships
      • Am I in a De Facto Relationship?
      • Breakdown of a De Facto Relationship – Fairbairn v Radecki
    • overseas orders
      • Impact of overseas divorce on Australian property settlement
      • Validity of Overseas Orders – Parenting, Marriage and Divorce Orders
      • Clayton & Bant – A multi-jurisdictional family law dispute
    • Property & Financial Settlement
      • Divorce Property Settlement Lawyers
      • Initial Contributions Count – 8 years + 1 child = 78%/82% to Husband
      • My Parents lent me money. Is it treated as a gift or a loan?
      • Difference between property and a financial resource in family law
      • Assessing initial contributions in a long relationship
      • The Alter Ego Principle – When a Spouse uses a trust to hide assets
      • CGT rollover for marriage breakdowns – Ellison & Sandini Explained
      • How Trusts are dealt with in a Property Settlement
      • Pet Custody – Who gets the dog in a divorce?
      • Redundancy payment – how is it treated?
      • Future inheritances – when can they be taken into account?
      • What is just and equitable?
      • Is domestic violence relevant in a property settlement?
      • Varying property orders
      • Defaulting on Property Orders is Dangerous
      • Effect of Bankruptcy on property settlement
      • Courtney’s Cases: Centrelink fraud or a fraudulent representation to the Court?
      • Limitation periods against solicitors for defective Financial Agreements
      • Court dismisses application for property settlement for same sex couple of 27 years
    • Binding Financial Agreements
      • Binding Financial Agreements
      • Is my Binding Financial Agreement Binding?
      • Does your Financial Agreement Protect you from a maintenance claim?
      • Superannuation Splitting in Financial Agreements
    • Child Support
      • Child Support Lawyers
      • I want to set aside a Binding Child Support Agreement
      • I want to challenge my child support assessment
    • Mediation Exemptions
      • Mediation
      • Can I go to court without doing mediation first?
      • Do I have to mediate before court? The exemptions Explained
      • NEWS ALERT – You do NOT need a s60I certificate to file your parenting application – Valack & Valack
    • Domestic Violence
      • Domestic Violence Lawyer – DVO – Domestic Violence Order
      • Common mistakes made in an application for a domestic violence order
      • Do’s and Don’ts when applying for a DVO to succeed
    • Narcissistic Abuse
      • What is Narcissistic Abuse and how to divorce a Narcissist
      • Top 10 Warning Signs of Narcissistic Abuse revealed
      • When is supervised time ordered? Is Narcissistic Abuse enough?
    • Unacceptable Risk
      • What is unacceptable risk & when will a Court change residence?
      • Mother’s persistent accusation that the Father sexually abused their child results in orders for no time with the Mother
      • Change in residence for children because of Mother’s inability to protect the children from harm
    • Evidence in parenting proceedings
      • Admissibility of opinion evidence & expert evidence in family law matters
      • Admissibility of recordings in family law cases
      • Admissibility of admissions at mediation in court proceedings
    • Covid-19
      • The Covid-19 Vaccination – Is mutual parental consent required?
      • I want to apply to the Family Court for inclusion in the Covid-19 List
    • Other Legal
      • NEWSFLASH – What are the New Family Law Rules?
      • Out With the Old, In With the New: Why Fixed Fees are better
      • Apprehended Bias – should Judges & lawyers have drinks pre-judgement?
      • Review of the Family Law System
      • Inquest of Jack & Jennifer Edwards – Lessons Learned
      • WARNING PRACTITIONERS: New Family Law Rules from 1 March 2018
  • Family Law Videos
  • Family Mediation
  • Contact Us
  • Success Stories
  • Narcissistic Abuse

What is unacceptable risk & when will a Court change residence?

July 7, 2022 By Barton Family Law

What is unacceptable risk?

In a parenting proceeding, it may be alleged that some serious harm has already occurred to a child and/or that the risk of harm to a child is likely to occur as a result of the actions of a parent, the court may find that the harm concerned constitutes an unacceptable risk of harm to the child in that parent’s care.

Risks of harm might include sexual or physical abuse, or other risks which affect the parenting capacity of a parent, including, for example, mental ill health of a party, alcohol or substance abuse, physical/intellectual impairment of a party or flight risk to a non-hague convention country.

When the court is required to determine what orders are in the best interests of a child, the court looks to what evidence there is of the risk occurring if the parent is granted time with the child, and the court must assess the magnitude of the risk.

The magnitude of the risk which will justify a court in denying a parent care of a child is if by providing the parent with care of a child, it exposes the child to an unacceptable risk of harm. The degree of risk has also been described as follows:

  • risk of serious harm;
  • an element of risk;
  • an appreciable risk;
  • a real possibility;
  • a real risk.

The unacceptable risk test is now found in the section 60CC considerations under the Family Law Act.

The two primary considerations under section 60CC in determining what orders are in a child’s interests are the child’s right to have a meaningful relationship with both parents, balanced against the child’s right to be protected from harm.

Where a child is at risk of physical or psychological harm, abuse or neglect in the care of one parent, their right to be protected from harm is given priority over the child’s right to have a relationship with that parent.

In some circumstances, this may necessitate a change of residence of a child in order to protect that child from harm they are suffering in the care of one parent.

In Willmore & Menendez, a change of residence was ordered from the Mother to the Father because of an unacceptable risk of harm to the child in the Mother’s unsupervised care.

Unacceptable Risk Case: Willmore & Menendez

In Willmore & Menendez the child was living with the Mother at separation and spending 3 nights a week with the Father, which the Mother suspended in 2010 and 2020 after interim orders were made following allegations by her that the Father had sexually abused the child.

A family report recommended overnight unsupervised time but despite this at the time of the trial the child was spending only two hours each alternate weekend with the Father. At trial the Mother maintained her allegations of sexual abuse, alleged the Father posed an unacceptable risk of harm to the child and sought supervised time.

The Father argued that the Mother made such allegations to remove the child from the Father’s life and in doing so posed an unacceptable risk of psychological abuse to the child in the Mother’s care. At trial Her Honour determined that the child (6) was at an unacceptable risk of psychological harm in the Mother’s care.

The Judge made orders that the Father have sole parental responsibility, that the child live with the Father and spend supervised time with the Mother for 2 years, transitioning to unsupervised time.

Unacceptable Risk Case on appeal

On appeal, the Full Court said that the primary judge explained her conclusion as to with whom the child should live, the benefits of the child’s relationship with the Mother as against the risks and how those risks might be minimised and having regard to these matters, what time the child should spend with the Mother, in her best interests.

The primary judge then provided reasons for making orders for the child to spend supervised time with the Mother for the first three months, however, she fell into error by failing to give adequate reasons for making orders that the child spend restricted supervised time with the Mother for a period of nearly two years and thereafter proposed an immediate re-introduction to unsupervised overnight time, continuous days and one half of all school holidays.

The Full Court said:

“In reaching that conclusion, her Honour was required to carefully outline why the risks that she identified, when balanced against the benefits of the child maintaining a meaningful relationship with the appellant, could not be ameliorated such that the child could spend time with the appellant, more frequently and in part unsupervised, prior to the expiration of a two year period.”

The case was remitted for rehearing before a different judge to deal with the issue of the time the child would spend with the mother, in what circumstances and upon what conditions.

unacceptable risk

Unacceptable risk of Harm & Change in residence applications

Are you concerned your children are at risk of unacceptable harm in the other parent’s household?

Are you seeking a change in residence?

We strongly encourage you to obtain prompt legal advice about the risk factors. If you sit and do nothing and allow the other parent to continue to spend time with the child without either (a) asserting the risk that exists and (b) commencing court proceedings, the Court may perceive that you do not believe that the children are at risk of harm in the other parent’s household, due to your failure to take action.

If you have concerns about your child being at an unacceptable risk of physical or psychological harm in the other parent’s are, contact us to book a reduced rate initial consultation with one of our experienced Brisbane Family Lawyers, to discuss your rights and formulate a plan to achieve the best possible outcome in your case and an outcome that ensures your children are protected from harm in the future.

Filed Under: unacceptable risk

Barton Family Law

Primary Sidebar

Online Enquiry

.

    I would like to book a reduced rate initial consultation with you

    Footer

    Areas of Practice

    • Child Custody Lawyers Brisbane
    • Divorce Property Settlement Lawyers
    • Fixed Fee Divorce Lawyers
    • Domestic Violence Lawyer – DVO Domestic Violence Order
    • Superannuation Splitting & Advice Lawyers
    • Fixed Fee Consent Orders Brisbane
    • Mediation Representation
    • Child Relocation Family Lawyers
    • Child Abduction Family Lawyers
    • Child Support Lawyers
    • Family Law Spousal Maintenance
    • Family Court Process
    • Family Mediation Services Brisbane
    • Binding Financial Agreements

    What makes us different from other Law Firms?

    Our Brisbane Divorce & Family Lawyers:

    • Only do family law all day every day. That makes us really good at what we do;
    • Are dedicated to helping you work through your family law issues so you can have a fresh start;
    • Have your best interests at heart;
    • Have the knowledge and experience to solve your family law problems, no matter how complex;
    • Will help you to reduce the conflict with your former partner;
    • Will fight for you and your children;
    • Provide exceptional quality service to you, tailored to your individual case needs;
    • Will educate you about your options, the steps you need to take and we will develop a strategy to help you to achieve a fair outcome and the best practical outcome for you and your family;
    • Will provide you with practical, realistic, commercial and strategic advice to empower you to make smart decisions following separation that will save you time, money and stress;
    • Will deliver an outcome to you quickly and cost effectively, with fixed fees for certainty;
    • Will do everything within our legal power to get you the best outcome for you and your family;
    • Are with you, supporting you, every step of the way from negotiations, to mediation, to litigation and settlement.
    Individual liability limited by a scheme approved under professional standards legislation.

    Contact Us

    Petrie Office

    • Address: 4/996 Anzac Avenue, Petrie QLD 4501
    • Parking: Underground parking available at the back of the building via O’Loan Street
    • Phone: 3465 9332
    • Email: [email protected]
    • Website: Petrie Family Lawyers

    Chermside Office

    • Address: 822 Gympie Road, Chermside QLD 4032
    • Phone: 3465 9332
    • Email: [email protected]
    • Website: Chermside Family Lawyers

    Aspley Office

    • Address: Aspley Hypermarket, 59 Albany Creek Road, Aspley QLD 4034
    • Phone: 3465 9332
    • Email: [email protected]
    • Website: Aspley Family Lawyers

    Copyright © 2022 | Website hosted by Lift Legal Marketing